12 Nov 2026 00:13:51
Excuse me for being naive but amongst all the talk about different systems, managers, directors of football and even owners
none of this matters unless the players are
1) properly fit
2) take personal responsibility
3) work for each other & manager
4) have football intelligence
5) have professional pride
6) appreciate the fans
Whether we get Poch or Pep the most important element is the character of the players. Get good characters and that's more than half the battle. Fergie knew it. All successful teams depend on good characters.
1.) 12 Nov 2026
12 Nov 2026 00:40:53
Ashley young was saying on goldbridge&rooney this week that the players set the standards for the club in terms of effort and workrate in training. And by the time moyes had left they had lost a lot of it.
Once SAF had set the tone, the dressing room maintained it themselves through the different generations of teams.
2.) 12 Nov 2026
12 Nov 2026 07:55:07
I'm actually feeling sorry for Poch that he's coming into a team who don't look up to Premier League fitness standards.
As much as those above Carrick let him down, Carrick also let the team down by not getting them fit during pre-season.
Whether or not he wanted to play a pressing system or a more possession based mid block, they were never going to succeed with out this basic fundamental.
Hope Carrick learns from this at his next job.
3.) 12 Nov 2026
12 Nov 2026 08:51:55
Carrick's next gig will probably be a podcast with Jonny Evans where they talk about the old days and slag off the current team.
Seems to be the go to option for ex United players, coaches, scouts etc. these days.
4.) 12 Nov 2026
12 Nov 2026 08:56:39
Fitness will be the biggest issue, I just don't see how we get that back especially at this stage of the season. The time for that was preseason but we dropped the ball massively in that aspect and now it's biting us in the backside.
5.) 12 Nov 2026
12 Nov 2026 13:00:43
A good manager can bring 1-6 out of them.
6.) 12 Nov 2026
12 Nov 2026 13:56:49
You're right, ultimately the reason clubs spend hundreds of millions on players is because the quality of your players is the single biggest factor in terms of team performance.
If we were to break down the impact of different factors for team performance:
Quality of players (Physical, technical, and mental) probably accounts for 70% of your performance.
Managers tactics maybe impact performances by 10%.
Coaching and training maybe impacts it by 10%.
Then the final 10% if down to how the opposition play, as well as marginal things like scheduling (when and where you play, as well as time to recover).
You might have a phenomenal manager, with a fantastic coaching team, and all the stars seem to align for you and all of that combined properly only accounts for 25% of the performance at most. How well you do is still mostly down to your players.
That is why even great managers like Pep have to completely rebuild the squads of the clubs they take over before you really see the impact they can have.
No manager will be able to make Harry Maguire quick and mobile, or keep Shaw fit, or turn Mbeumo into a target man striker.
I get incredibly frustrated with our players, but I genuinely don't think they are bad eggs (with the exception of a few). I just think that the majority of them lack that real killer mentality. I think there are too many sheep who'll blindly follow the loudest voice. They aren't bad players, you could definitely question whether they are top class (most of them aren't), but they aren't bad players. They just seem to lack that elite mentality. When they chips are down they don't have the ability to use that to fire themselves up, they give in to it, accept it, embrace it. Which is why they need a change in manager to come in and change the atmosphere in order for their performances to improve. Because they lack the autonomy to shift their own perspective.
We need to shift out the few bad eggs (Rashford), as well as those who just aren't good enough, and more importantly than signing top players, we need to sign players with that elite mentality and natural leadership.
People talk about Liverpool under Klopp, but the biggest factor in their success was moving Gerrard out and bringing Henderson in. On paper and on the pitch Gerrard was the far more talented player. But his mentality was too self-centred and as such no one else could step out of his shadow and the club relied on him to perform to do well. Henderson on the other hand was an absolute mentality monster, he demanded the best from himself, and he dragged the best out of his teammates. Making Liverpool a better team. They also had players like Milner who was the same.
That is what we are missing, players with the mentality and personalities like Henderson and Milner. And until we get 4 or 5 players into this squad with that mentality then we will struggle to do anything but move between new manager bounce followed by decline until the next new manager bounce.