Manchester United Rumours Member Posts

 

3_Lung_Park's Profile


Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded

3_Lung_Park's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To 3_Lung_Park's Posts

 

 

To 3_Lung_Park's last 5 rumours posts

 

To 3_Lung_Park's last 5 banter posts

 

To 3_Lung_Park's last 5 rumour replies

 

To 3_Lung_Park's last 5 banter replies

 

3_Lung_Park's rumours posts with other poster's replies to 3_Lung_Park's rumours posts

 

15 Nov 2026 21:51:10
Watching England tonight it is unbelievable that we didn’t do everything possible to sign Hall in the summer. Would have been perfect for us and solidified that left hand side.

Oh well, on the upside, plenty of rumours that we are up for sale. If so, we can only dream of having owners who genuinely care if we do well or not.

3_Lung_Park

1.) 15 Nov 2026 22:21:44
He was very good tonight Park. Although we must have in mind that international football is different. In Premier he hadn't started as strong.


2.) 16 Nov 2026 11:40:13
He's a very good player, but ultimately Newcastle had no need or intention of selling him. It would have taken a stupid offer to even get them to consider it.

Also while I rate Hall, international football is a terrible standard to use to judge a player.


 

 

06 Oct 2026 11:43:27
So Conte has thrown his name in the ring

Feels like Groundhog Day but what are people's views on this?

At Napoli he won the league whilst moving away from his trademark 3 at the back (which is what put me off originally).

Seems to be an excellent motivator before exploding - again this used to bother me but we don't keep managers for more than 2 years anyway atm so is this even a problem anymore?

(Note: I still want Carrick to succeed and think any manager would struggle with the full backs we have but would be interested by the overall consensus)

3_Lung_Park

1.) 06 Oct 2026 21:08:00
Conte is on another planet compared to Carrick. Conte would not allow slackers and makes teams run. Tactically astute.

Certainly would shake everything up. However to save you the wait, people will just say there is no one better than our Michael, so we must not be unfaithful even mentioning anyone else's name.

Bit torn on Conte, top manager but there will be strife whilst he drives change. Miles better than what we have. Intrigued by Hurzeler mind you and wonder if that is more the direction, a young vibrant coach. We had one but didn't stand behind him.


2.) 07 Oct 2026 10:58:13
I'd snap him up in a flash.
No need question. He is better than better than anyone we've had since Ferguson, barring Mourinho.
In fact, he could have a similar impact that Mourinho had. Competing in the cup competitions at the least.


Currently, we're being knocked out in the early rounds with pathetic displays.
Getting some trophies, whether that's League cup and Europa, would be a boost for some of our younger squad.


3.) 07 Oct 2026 15:27:31
Hes a serial winner, that's for sure, and he would certainly shake things up. It would be very entertaining but potentially short lived.


4.) 08 Oct 2026 06:41:02
Conte is a serial winner. I would not be concerned about him staying for a sustained period.
I think we would do better under him than under a lot of coaches.


5.) 08 Oct 2026 14:39:47
Conte wouldn't last 5 minutes under the current structure. He'd call the board out like Amorim did and get sacked.


6.) 09 Oct 2026 04:19:11
Rewz is spot on.
I've been fortunate enough to understand how mental my own physiological profile is thought myers bring.

Conte is pure ENTJ. Google it.

He will get frustrated by how inept the back office is and go bananas.

But I'd love him, love the type. And Would hire the type. I have an expression passed on from an old director. He used to say I'd rather have someone good for 2–3 years than some one an average for 5 years.

I'd rather have someone excellent for a year or so like conte than have some average bloke.


7.) 09 Oct 2026 18:25:53
Be hilarious thou. watching conte explode on touchline. especially someone like dalot ?.


8.) 10 Oct 2026 10:17:54
He's a great coach without a shadow of a doubt, but it is because he does things like this which is why I think he would ultimately be a poor appointment.

It was a thinly veiled plea for a job that isn't currently available, to intentionally put that pressure on another manager (which could and have negative impacts on the club) in an attempt to try and secure himself a position, does not show the kind of character I'd want in a manager of our club.

That is without even considering his playing style (which I've not particularly been a fan of over the years).

Great manager in terms of success, but tends to be a short term fix to get a couple extra years out of a declining great team. He doesn't tend to build for the future, is particularly successful with developing young players, and rarely last more than 3 years at a club before it all implodes or he falls out with everyone.

Which his recent comments probably shed some light on why he might rub people up the wrong way and fall out with people.


9.) 10 Oct 2026 20:10:16
I'd take a short term fix at this point. I'm sick of watching the dross week in, week out.


 

 

20 Sep 2026 18:08:47
Get Emery.

3_Lung_Park

1.) 21 Sep 2026 05:55:37
It doesn't matter who we get, if they don't have final say over players being targeted, players being sold and players being selected, it is a poisoned chalice.


2.) 21 Sep 2026 08:42:16
Yup. At this point, Wilcox out is the only logical play.


3.) 21 Sep 2026 13:23:47
It will be the same s*** show no matter who comes in.

That kind of performance is just standard now for United.


4.) 22 Sep 2026 05:46:03
While I agree that we need to fix the leaky roof before changing the carpet, MC has to take some of the blame. Amorim built up fitness levels throughout the squad. We've become lazy and out of shape since he left. It's not good enough.


5.) 22 Sep 2026 12:28:45
I am not convinced at all by Carrick - his credentials or his demeanor at every press conference I've seen. I don't find him convincing inspiring at all and I feel he benefited from a good old bout of new manager bounce when he first came in.
But. I don't think fitness levels, coaching and tactics are all his fault.

Yes he should be implementing and communicating these during games, and again he doesn't seem particularly vocal or proactive in this regard. But there is a whole host of coaches responsible for this during the week. He can't be solely responsible. Seriously, Woodgate and Evans? They have as little experience and clout as Carrick.


6.) 22 Sep 2026 22:41:34
Bang on redseven. MC rode the Amorim wave all the way to the bank and the hierarchy fell for it again.

Said hierarchy needs to look at Wilcox and Berrada. They have sold the plan of title challengers next season, or is the season after. Either way, we are closer to relegation form than title winning form, with a squad so far out of shape it isn't funny.

The club is void of standards. It is a global embarrassment.


7.) 23 Sep 2026 16:17:37
Record revenue for club announced. I dare say the owners think he is doing a great job. Director football is the role to address.


 

 

 

3_Lung_Park's banter posts with other poster's replies to 3_Lung_Park's banter posts

 

25 Oct 2026 20:02:12
It's a strange feeling at the moment as I flip from blaming one group to the other but today I don't feel like this is the players fault.

Carrick is a legend but pre-season Tielemans was interviewed saying about the lack of fitness training so there is no surprise that he and others looks way off it.

Surely the fundamentals of 'earn the right to play' starts with fitness. You can have the worlds best 11 on paper (which obviously we don't have) but if they are unfit - then you are going to get beat by teams that are - it's not rocket science, it's not even grade 1 literacy, it's basic common sense.

Carrick saying there's more than one way to beat an opponent is fine but it's clear we are letting the opposition do what they want. Being so worried about covering for our defensive frailty's and not putting pressure on the opponent is making us worse not better.

We are in a relegation scrap, Manchester United - the biggest team in England, is in a relegation scrap. That genuinely hurts to say. Even Carrick will admit that enough is enough.

The worse thing is - replace Carrick, Wilcox will still be above, replace Wilcox you have Jim Ratcliffe - the chem dealer, remove him and you still have the Glazer leaches who never put a penny into this club and took everything out. The rot is so deep that even with the miracle that each and every one of those dream killing scum bags taken out of the club it's hard to see the damage being fixed.

My favourite song is Glory Glory Man United the f*** do we sing now.

3_Lung_Park

1.) 25 Oct 2026 21:34:03
I had a terrible thought after today's game.

What if they bring OGS back until the end of the season?


2.) 25 Oct 2026 22:24:11
I don't see how Carrick can be blamed. He got the feel good feeling back and got you CL football. Then it's got a little bit rough and the players have downed tools again as they know the manger cops it. In my opinion they are the common thread through all this manager merry go round.

The cycle will repeat until the dressing room is sorted.

Carrick isn't without fault, but the powers that be didn't learn the last time a former player did well and got the job. He should have been thanked and you should have moved on. Most football fans saw it, yet the hierarchy took the easy choice. Now your back to square one. Those guys are paid big bucks to make tough decisions and should have been able to see where this would go.

However, I don't think you'll be in a scrap. A new manager will come in where the players will respond. Then Itll get tough and he will be sacked in a year or two.

Just one last point on the players, yes they are given tactics but they still are the ones on the pitch. They can still deliver and put 100% in, right now are any of them doing that for the fans? It's the bare minimum and they should be able to motivate themselves and have some pride in what they are showing.


3.) 26 Oct 2026 14:25:28
WYred, I'm assuming you haven't seen the football, the lack of effort, the keep compact and don't press tactics that have come from the coaching staff as per the player's words and the coach.

Is it on the players as well? Sure, but something seems extremely off when players join the club and say we're not running.


 

 

23 Oct 2026 06:20:46
In the past I've always tried to back the manager for as long as possible but it's clear the players don't want to play for Carrick.

When your captain comes out and speaks publicly about his tactics, you would think it's the thoughts of many of the players, so I don't see the point in delaying the inevitable.

What I don't like is that the players, who have always failed to deliver a functional high press btw, have completely rejected a different type of tactic. Player power is clearly rife and not giving the manager a real chance.

Therefore, the next appointment needs to have a strong character with a CV that they can't question. It has to be Conte for me.

What a mess my club has turned into. There is a sham club across the city but there are sham owners inside our boardroom.

3_Lung_Park

1.) 23 Oct 2026 09:24:19
Park
Unfortunatly i'd very much doubt conte would even be in the running. He would call someone out within a month.
This board and ownership won't be questioned if there was any sense wilcox would be gone.

Instead he will pick eddie howe who was lucky to last the season at newcastle.
Players that have had upteen chances under different managers will get another go! until we have a full clearout it will be rinse and repeat.


2.) 23 Oct 2026 09:27:40
I'm not sure it matters at this stage. This club is badly broken and if I was a player I'd be asking my agent to get me out and it's a big risk for a quality manager to take on right now. Give it to Phil Brown for all I care.


3.) 23 Oct 2026 09:57:00
Lets not kid ourselves, it will be someone who is another yes man or not good enough. Kieran Mckenna or Southgate come to mind.

The club will appoint to its level, which is a midtable team with no aspiration. No doubt SJR or Wilcox will make a statement trying to gaslight the fans into thinking it was a good decision.

Sick of this ownership, the players and the club as a whole at the minute.


4.) 23 Oct 2026 11:25:28
Howe is the only realistic and sensible option.

Not a sexy name so many here will deride the choice. But he's the only logical choice right now. Nobody else worth their salt would want it.

And I think the last thing we need is another "master tactician" like Nagelsman confusing the clearly very basic players we have.


5.) 23 Oct 2026 13:12:31
Eddie Howe really isn't good enough and if we go down that path we will be no better off in a years time.


6.) 23 Oct 2026 11:56:00
Eddie Howe is no better than Carrick. Conte is mental. He'd be off in 2 months with a strop. Nagelsmann would be a major risk. The only credible successor to steady the ship and to progress the cub would be Unai Emery.


7.) 23 Oct 2026 13:42:00
Howe isn't good enough for what exactly?

We don't have a squad capable enough to win trophies or implement complicated strategies. Someone like Conte or Naglesman would run into the exact same issues Amorim did. Players that don't have the ability to do what's asked of them.

Our squad is at a level where they should be battling for the last CL place. That's where we are. The only way we'll improve is by getting regular CL football and bringing in a director of football/scouting team capable of identifying quality players early in their career.

Howe has proven that he can get results with limited squads. His approach is simple, but far more competent than Carrick's. Howe and a proven director of football could help lay the foundations for bringing in an elite manager a few years down the line. People need to stop buying into the club's BS that were a big club. We're not. United are not equipped for an elite manager. Howe is the level we're at.


8.) 23 Oct 2026 13:50:35
To move on its need to remove Wilcox. Let Vivell pick the next manager. The choices Wilcox has made, have failed drastically.


9.) 23 Oct 2026 15:57:07
Vivell and nagelsman?
I think the whole coaching staff will need to go, so it would be a very big change.

They will desperately want a turn around in fortunes.


10.) 23 Oct 2026 17:01:09
DB,

The current coaching setup isn't good enough. If Carrick goes, then whoever the new manager is, will bring in their trusted coaching staff.


11.) 23 Oct 2026 17:30:48
Did I just read Howe is no better than Carrick?


12.) 23 Oct 2026 18:00:22
What under strength squad did howe have success with? .
Eng rb eng lb now a barca lw aresenal cm Liverpool striker. He had plenty of good players. Yes he got them playing well for a coule of seadons but imo he should have done better with that team than he did not withstanding the fact that he did pretty well. But never as high as 3rd.
He would be a seady eddie.
Might be a decent shout short term to take over mid season he seems like a good calm charachter he is used to working in a nuthouse restricted environment.
He would not be my choice but neither was carrick ole or eth so that in itself suggests Howe has a good chance of getting it?

Id rather go with naglesmann or conte and let a looney run the asylum for a bit it might be just what the doctor ordered.


13.) 24 Oct 2026 12:11:54
Howe is no better than Carrick is one of the best posts on here. This club has no bloody chance because if we get Howe it's a great move but there are fans who would only want someone with a foreign name and actually think he's not a better coach than Carrick!


 

 

12 Aug 2026 11:00:36
Marcus Rashford - Got to be the most controversial figure in our club right now.

And maybe it’s the football romantic in me but I’m hoping for a resurgence. Still remember his debut brace and he’s still one of our own.



Hoping people give him a chance and Carrick gets the best out of him as he fixes a couple of squad issues if he comes in all guns firing.

3_Lung_Park

1.) 12 Aug 2026 13:14:51.
I was at that game, coming back to Manchester for a quick visit. Took the wife, who traitorously had become an Arsenal supporter. Grounds for divorce? It was a game we were expected to lose, or at least struggle in. Anyway, that intense surrounding, mainly male energy when the crowd rose after the winner went in, caused her to rethink her commitment to supporting any team at all.

She ended up deciding she was no longer going to invest all that emotion into it, and pulled back completely. Nary a peep from her since! Saved the marriage!

Mind you, she was attracted to Arsenal when they were playing some very attractive football under Wenger's professorial management. I suspect that she would never have strayed today, given how unattractive they are today.


2.) 12 Aug 2026 15:09:20
It's all gone a bit Ron Manager there.


3.) 12 Aug 2026 17:48:04
The romanticism of him falling back in love with the club and getting back to his best would be great to see. I just doubt it will happen, while some fans are incapable of moving on. Once they decide they don't like a player, nothing can convince them to change that view.


4.) 12 Aug 2026 18:28:49
If he wasn't already here, would we be trying to buy him? I doubt it. Late for training, fallen out with a couple of managers, questionable effort, £325K a week, we wouldn't be anywhere near it.



I'm not going to hold a grudge, but let's be honest, we are stuck with him. If anyone thinks he is suddenly going to be a great, highly motivated, and committed player, I fear you will be disappointed.


5.) 12 Aug 2026 19:30:33
The biggest issue with Rashford is that he has never really tried to develop his all round game.

If you think back to his first season, his game was about operating high and wide to get in behind the defence with his pace, cutting in and shooting. Nothing has really changed since then.

It has always felt like he thought he should have a Ronaldo role without defensive responsibilities, and the team set up to counterattack to suit his game. The issue is that he was never close to being as clinical as Ronaldo. If he had worked on his defending, passing, dribbling ability, added anything else to his game, he could have been top class.

Watching him at the World Cup, his limitations are obvious. Struggles to beat defenders with the ball, and very limited tracking back.

We're fools for giving him a massive wage, and now we're stuck with him. Personally, I feel like he's going to be a distraction this season, with lots of media attention on his role, game time, etc. Think everyone at the club would rather that he moved on. But he's not going to take the drastic wage reduction required to convince another club to buy him.


6.) 13 Aug 2026 08:40:40
I very much agree with AJH on Rashford and want him gone.
Whilst I agree with you, Danny, I take issue with the first sentence of your post. Personally I think the biggest issue with Rashford is that he has become a self opinionated, entitled, selfish d***.


 

 

 

3_Lung_Park's rumour replies

 

Click To View This Thread

21 Oct 2026 22:42:16
See for years we've complained about chopping and changing tactically so Conte might have been a good idea if it was straight after Amorim but that's not our club is run.

3_Lung_Park

 

 

Click To View This Thread

20 Sep 2026 18:06:43
The whole team is playing sh*te but somehow it's always Rashford's fault. Cunha, Dalot, Mbuemo, Tielmans, Maguire, Shaw, the whole team are walking.

When it's the whole team you got to think the manager needs to put a rocket up them but he's looking as lost as his team right now.

Not saying Rash has been great but some fans are just obsessed with only blaming one person.

3_Lung_Park

 

 

Click To View This Thread

20 Sep 2026 01:16:21
Do you think we could get Emry out of Villa?

Just had most of his team dismantled. If there was anyone who might be dislodged atm

Not asking for Carrick to go at all but would be one of the few people I'd be happy with as a replacement.

3_Lung_Park

{Ed0666's Note - you kind of are asking for Carrick to go if you’re talking about his successor. Personally I think you guys should get steady Eddie for a couple of seasons, take a beat consolidate, get top 4, earn some money and then mount a title challenge in a couple of seasons..then go for the big name managers/coaches like Enrique’s of the world.


 

 

 

3_Lung_Park's banter replies

 

Click To View This Thread

12 Nov 2026 07:55:07
I'm actually feeling sorry for Poch that he's coming into a team who don't look up to Premier League fitness standards.

As much as those above Carrick let him down, Carrick also let the team down by not getting them fit during pre-season.

Whether or not he wanted to play a pressing system or a more possession based mid block, they were never going to succeed with out this basic fundamental.

Hope Carrick learns from this at his next job.

3_Lung_Park

 

 

Click To View This Thread

26 Oct 2026 14:25:28
WYred, I'm assuming you haven't seen the football, the lack of effort, the keep compact and don't press tactics that have come from the coaching staff as per the player's words and the coach.

Is it on the players as well? Sure, but something seems extremely off when players join the club and say we're not running.

3_Lung_Park

 

 

Click To View This Thread

25 Oct 2026 15:29:46
Now I'm not saying INEOS are good but they are still hamstrung by the majority owners who will still be in charge of what can be spent at the end of the day.

3_Lung_Park

 

 

Click To View This Thread

06 Oct 2026 11:34:06
I really liked Yoro at right back during pre-season. Felt like he gave more going forward and defensively then Dalot (although admittedly the sample size was very small)

3_Lung_Park

 

 

Click To View This Thread

06 Oct 2026 11:32:38
Careful what you wish for, seeing as City are likely to be booted out of the Prem before that happens might not be the best idea

(Obviously I would love the Glazers out though)

3_Lung_Park

 

 





Change Consent