Manchester United Rumours Member Posts

 

Rjmanutd's Profile

Current Avatar:
Rjmanutd's Avatar
Flat Out Racing:

Not played Flat Out Racing


No Profile Picture uploaded

Team: Manchester United


Where from: Dunfermline


Favourite player: Paul Scholes


Best team moment: 99 Champions League final.


Interests:


Timezone:




Rjmanutd's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Rjmanutd's Posts

 

 

To Rjmanutd's last 5 rumours posts

 

To Rjmanutd's last 5 banter posts

 

To Rjmanutd's last 5 rumour replies

 

To Rjmanutd's last 5 banter replies

 

Rjmanutd's rumours posts with other poster's replies to Rjmanutd's rumours posts

 

14 Apr 2022 11:43:01
Hi Ed002 hope you are well?

Do you have any insight on what is likely to happen with Marcus Rashford this summer? His form has obviously fallen off a cliff in the last year or so, possibly down to lack of pre season, playing through injury last season and pretty much never being given a rest under Ole.

However, he has a lot of ability and he's a local lad who's come through the academy and in my opinion despite his lack of form, should be well down the list of those who should be leaving, with plenty of others ahead of him.

Do you see him being sold and are the clubs like PSG who have previously looked at him still interested?

Thanks very much.

Rjmanutd

{Ed002's Note - Marcus Rashford (F) has an uncertain future at Manchester United although there has been no final decision. PSG have enquired although their interest has now gone. He may provide an option for Arsenal who could shift their interest to him. Right now he would be difficult to sell and perhaps a loan away would benefit him. The club is certainly considering options.}


1.) 14 Apr 2022 12:58:29
ED002,

Is or true the club have asked him to cut back back on his offield duties to concentrate on his football? .

Thanks.

{Ed002's Note - Sorry, I really don't know.}


2.) 14 Apr 2022 13:49:23
Thanks for the update Ed002, I'd certainly be disappointed to see Rashford leave, he looked like a player to build a squad around a couple of years ago. Have a good day.


3.) 14 Apr 2022 23:22:06
Ed002. Why do you say rashford would be difficult to sell?

{Ed007's Note - Because he's pish maybe?}


 

 

26 Jan 2022 11:41:18
Hi Ed, hope you are well?

Is there any indication as to who United will target as our back up keeper? I'll hazard a guess that we may go for Sam Johnstone since he is out of contract.

Likely we see Henderson go either on loan or permanent and Heaton is a solid 3rd choice but likely not going to be 2nd.

Rjmanutd

{Ed002's Note - The club will not be rushed in to making a decision.}


1.) 26 Jan 2022 16:33:57
Kovar might be brought through, he is well thought of at the club. Depends on who the new manager is though.


 

 

10 Nov 2021 10:39:34
Hi Ed, hope you are well?

While it doesn't look like United have any plans to replace Ole in the short term, will the situation have any impact on any potential signings or outgoings in January? Never the easiest time for transfers at the best of times anyway.

I'd hazard a guess that players like Van De Beek, Martial, Lingard and maybe a couple of others will be the likeliest to leave if Ole stays until then.

Cheers.

Rjmanutd

{Ed002's Note - No it will not directly impact January. Typically clubs do not plan for too much change in January.}


1.) 10 Nov 2021 11:56:30
Looking at our squad I'd have thought January was more about moving on players rather than signing new ones.

Like you say Donny, Martial and Lingard will be considering their futures.

As should Jones, Tuanzebe and Bailly, maybe even Dalot.

Henderson will probably be looking to leave with DDG now re-establish first choice.

Pogba won't leave until the summer, which is probably the same for Mata, Cavani and Matic.

I don't think the sort of signings we need or would look to make will be available in January regardless of who are manager is at the time.


2.) 10 Nov 2021 16:52:52
Of course the plan would be to buy a marquee midfielder in summer, but Ole might well be looking in January and have doubts (like the rest of the population) over whether he's going to be in place to see that happen.

Maybe he'll resort to something in January to tackle it while he has a say. That midfield is a complete mess. There are grey areas over Pogba, Matic and VDB while neither Fred nor McT are up to it. You could easily argue that Utd might need 2-3 midfielders in the next year one way or the other and they needn't all be marquee signings, just the right signings.

Much 'lesser' players are looking much more tempting than anything we've forked out a lot of money for.


3.) 10 Nov 2021 21:15:05
Absolute travesty if VDB leaves. We should be looking to build around players like VDB, Sancho and Rashford. Not leave two of them on the bench and run the other into the ground.

I still maintain that not making a DM our top priority (maybe joint with CB) was a huge mistake this summer, but I'm gradually coming to wonder whether keeping Ole wasn't an even bigger one.

And yes, even this summer I supported Ole. I felt that he hadn't done badly with the players he had, and felt that the clubs poor running and terrible "negotiating" practices were the main problem. I thought this Summer was the time to get in the 3 or so players needed to finally make the team click. Ole didn't do that, and has failed to progress the team significantly from last season. I was wrong.


4.) 10 Nov 2021 22:58:54
For all of his faults I don’t think Ole can be personally held account for not signing this or that player. We can assume clubs identify areas to strengthen then come up with a list of the ideal signings for those positions. At least I remember Mourinho saying this was how he worked. He was getting players 4-5th on his list. We have to at least assume Ole identified CM, but for whatever reason those above him couldn’t sign the top names on that list so maybe learned from the past and decided to wait rather than settle for 4th-5th choice names again. At least I would like to think so….


5.) 11 Nov 2021 11:34:42
Oh, I realise that Ole won't have direct control of transfers, but surely if he sits down in the meeting at the start of the window and says:

"Look, we need someone at right wing, and a more attack minded right back would be great if someone suitable is available, but no matter what, we absolutely need two players: a more mobile partner for Harry at the back, and a proper defensive midfielder to replace the headless chicken. "

I find it hard to believe that they wouldn't have sorted something out. It's not like there weren't any decent DMs available this summer, and IMO the need was serious enough to not wait for our first choice. Even if we couldn't get our first choice, surely we want 2 DMs in the long term anyway, a first choice and a backup/ rotation option. We could easily have brought in someone who improved on Fred at the very least.

So while I realize Ole isn't directly responsible, I still blame him for not pushing hard enough, presumably because he's content with Fred.

I also find it hard to believe that McT couldn't do a passable job in the role. Give him orders to hold back and protect the back line and pair him up with VDB, can't be worse than McFred, but Ole shows no signs of even trying anything like this, despite VDB showing more ability in the few minutes he's had so far than Fred has shown in his entire time at the club.


6.) 12 Nov 2021 01:06:54
Whilst I don't think mctominay has discipline enough to play dm at a great level, I definitely think he can do a job there. Especially with him experiencing gametime at cb with scotland.

Him with dvb is how I would go for sure. Dvb with matic some games too.


 

 

14 Jul 2021 12:39:18
Hi Ed, hope you are well?

Has there been any progress on any outgoing players at United so far this summer? Our squad is huge and is about to get bigger with Sancho and maybe Varane arriving.

Players like Jones, Dalot, Williams, Lingard, Pereira etc all taking up space but would at best make the bench. I'm guessing we've already priced players out of a move this summer as well.

Rjmanutd

{Ed002's Note - Agents are working on finding homes for players who are available to move on.}


1.) 14 Jul 2021 13:12:29
Roma in talks for Alex Telles apparently.


2.) 14 Jul 2021 13:41:35
Thanks very much Ed. Good to know that work is ongoing to at least try to move on some of these players.

Just waiting for Phil Jones to pick up his next injury that rules him out until after the transfer window closes.


3.) 14 Jul 2021 13:54:35
Of all the players at the club who aren't regular first choice in their position, Telles is one of the few who I don't understand why we'd let him go easily. Telles is a good player, that's the level we want our backup players to be.


4.) 14 Jul 2021 18:57:23
It was manic to Rome then bailley then dalot now telles.


5.) 15 Jul 2021 07:58:07
To be honest while our in coming transfers have been poorly handled on the whole. It is the out goings that are the real problem.

Romero, Jones, Dalot, Matic, Mata, Lingard, Andreas Pereira and Chong all need to leave on permanent deals.

One of Henderson or DDG need to move on. As does one of Bailly or Tuanzebe.
Does James have a long term future, should he leave permanently or on loan.
Pogba needs to be moved on.
What is the situation with Donny? Does he stay and fight for a place, or does he leave?

Then we have the players who need loans sorted out. Mengi, Laird, Williams, Garner, Hannibal, Pellistri, Shoretire, Elanga, maybe even Amad.

We have a bloated squad, many of whom are either not good enough or on the decline. They block the pathway for our talented young academy players, and restrict our ability to sign new players.

While our signings have been very hit and miss, while lacking in being part of a cohesive larger vision.

However, it is the inability to move players on that is the real failing.


6.) 15 Jul 2021 14:16:41
Shappy - "However, it is the inability to move players on that is the real failing. " totally agree but as said before there are other problems at utd from the infastructure, building etc down to the p. poor customer/ fan service in certain areas.


7.) 15 Jul 2021 15:24:51
Funky, of course there are loads of other issues top to bottom. All I'm really talking about is the issues with creating/ assembling a team capable of challenging for top honours.

I suspect that if like when Sir Alex was in charge the team is performing well and winning titles. Then I suspect for most fans the poor investment in infrastructure/ fan service etc wouldn't be such an issue.

However, not having a team that is consistently challenging means the spot light is drawn on all areas of the Glazer ownership in an attempt to find out what is going wrong.


8.) 16 Jul 2021 08:58:39
re -read Shappy agree with you - adding further that the whole infastructure and everything mufc needs addressing. Like a lot of things in life and business taking the eye off seemingly smaller issues can / does effect the bigger ones or those perceived as such.
I read all the eds comments as you probably do and its blatantly obvious deuction that the club is run in an amateurish way, pointed out numerous times Ed002 is it not?
Lets face it, we are not a total football club, we are a multi million business and can't seriously succed if we are run from a b&q shed by someones uncles first boyfriend who had a football in his nans garden!
I agree the playing staff and indeed it commands mega bucks, but its taken 2 decades to get a director of football and probably a decade since carrington was given £200 worth of paint. I want us to be despised on all fronts not just the envy of fans for trophies that we have tried to win with over 1 billion of investment- not that much different to spurs over the last 8 years in that way but they have amazing facilities and a cracking stadium- and you can get the phone answered by a bloody human!


 

 

09 Jun 2021 12:58:40
Hi ed002, hope you are well?

Quick question about Diogo Dalot. Looks like the club are happy to sell him and with Mourinho taking over at Roma, do you see Roma becoming interested in signing him?

Obviously, Mourinho was the manager that brought him to United and you've mentioned in the past he was of interest when Mourinho was at Spurs.

Thanks.

Rjmanutd

{Ed002's Note - Diogo Dalot (RB/LB) Milan want a cheap deal or another loan if they can but it will depend on Manchester United adding a replacement as cover. Milan have other options they are considering and want an early answer. I expect he will leave in the summer. No interest from Roma who have other plans.}


1.) 09 Jun 2021 15:32:26
Cheers ed.


2.) 09 Jun 2021 22:10:42
Smart move by the board to let a player who might be a potential regular Portugal fullback who can play both fullback positions, and is on lower wages and would be a good no2.
Didn't city sign somewhat similar play in cancelo for 2-3 times he's worth?
Our board and their stupid decision making.


3.) 10 Jun 2021 06:58:40
rohanarora8, and probably Ole doesn't rate him either.

Maybe it's a lot more fun throwing money around at other clubs and agents to sign their players and then struggle to sell the same players in a few years time.


4.) 10 Jun 2021 08:15:41
He is not that good defensively that's why we are selling him. Check out euro 21 semifinal, single handedly gave the other team a chance for a comeback. Made 2 errors leading to goals when in fact he was one of the most experienced player in the squad.


5.) 10 Jun 2021 09:49:32
Dalot might be able to play both the fullback positions, but he's average at best at both. I doubt comparing Cancelo with Dalot is fair, as the former is (as much as it hurts me to say) a much better player than Dalot.


6.) 15 Jun 2021 16:56:16
Rohan, while Cancelo is fit, Dalot will not be a regular Portugal player.


 

 

 

Rjmanutd's banter posts with other poster's replies to Rjmanutd's banter posts

 

07 May 2022 20:37:38
There are plenty of expletives to describe just how bad that performance was but let's just say it was well below par.

I've seen sides with poor defensive organisation, I've seen players who lack effort or willingness to defend and I've seen sides with players who aren't good enough defensively but rarely do you see a side combine all three of these into the mess we're currently in.

Another point I think is worth making is about De Gea. He's been one of our better players this season and while he is not everyone's favourite he hasn't been objectively terrible like so many others. Despite this, he is beaten from distance more often than he should be. Is it his footwork? Concentration? Not sure but it's a concern as while the strike today and the Xhaka one were well hit and he may have been unsighted, neither were unsaveable in my opinion.

Rjmanutd

1.) 07 May 2022 20:57:05
De Gae is a fantastic shot stopper but watching games, it seems, nothing else. I don't think it would be the end of the world if we let him go as well as the rest of them.


 

 

21 Apr 2022 06:56:16
Ed001, I'd be interested in your opinion on the current state of things at United. You've seen your side simply obliterate us twice this season, however, Liverpool have been in not too dissimilar positions to United over the past 25 years, though I don't think I've seen a side throw in the towel quite as much as this United side.

What and where do you think the first changes are needed and do you think ten Hag is the right person to implement then?

Rjmanutd

{Ed001's Note - the first changes were really needed above ten Hag, with the replacement of Woodward, which has happened. Only time will tell if it is the right guy, but it the club is run with the football side as priority instead of the business, it will come a long way forward.

That is the main thing, it is making decisions based on what best suits the football team, rather than sponsors etc. That should hopefully be the remit for the long term future.

As for ten Hag, I think he is probably the best available option right now that will be a big enough name to get the vast majority of fans onside. If you can't united the fanbase, then the manager has no chance.}


1.) 21 Apr 2022 15:34:39
Ed001, I think that's a fair assesment. I think United have now fallen into that dreaded category of "sleeping giant".

We have the global appeal and financial clout to drag ourselves out of this apathy but we need to have the will to do what is needed, and be humble enough to admit to our failings and have the resolve aim for better.

However, it always starts at the top. While the Glazers leave the running of the club up to others, it is still run on their behalf in their image. If not then surely they would remove the people who aren't running the club as they want it to be.

I have concerns with Richard Arnold, he seems to have been the man to follow Woodward around and pick up his sloppy seconds. Yet he has said the right things, so I reserve judgement for now.

My concern is clearly they're is a lack of knowhow in running a football club within the club. They have used consultants in the past and have brought in Rangnick in part for his expertise. Yet there stills seems to an arrogance from the club that they know better than the people for whose knowledge they are paying a handsome price.

I wonder if we have people at the club who prefer to surround themselves with "yes" men, people who'll just agree with them rather than challenge them when their thinking might be flawed. They certainly don't seem to trust anyone who thinks differently to them.

It's a long road back, and there will be mistakes along the way. We need to run the club as a football club, we need to support the manager, we need to be patient, and we as a fan base need to support the manager, rather than stick the knife in after every poor result.

{Ed001's Note - that is a big problem with powerful people, they don't like to be told no.}


2.) 21 Apr 2022 16:58:24
The main thing I'm looking forward to is the fact he has had his teams play good football. We're not expecting overnight miracles with Ten Hag but hopefully the big difference initially is that we play with a clear plan and play some relatively entertaining football. This obviously depends on the players actually doing what they're told and having the ability to do it but United playing attacking football and scoring goals again is something to look forward to even if they are still going on the other end.

Cheers for your thoughts Ed.

{Ed001's Note - very welcome mate.}


 

 

26 Oct 2021 09:39:10
Looking more and more likely Ole is staying. Absolutely dumbfounded if that happens. Surely it is only until there is a decision on who they should go for? Spurs then Atalanta away then City doesn't give a new manager much time on the training pitch to coach. Maybe get through that then he goes?

Potter, Ten Hag, Favre would be among my favourites for the job but Conte looked like the front runner. Can only assume there's a bit of disagreement about whether Conte would take us in the direction the club want and not just be a repeat of Jose?

Rjmanutd

1.) 26 Oct 2021 10:02:11
What direction is that RJM? As I have no idea where we are going I se this current manager?


2.) 26 Oct 2021 10:23:08
Totally agree Eric. We are going nowhere right now but if it's a case of taking slightly more time to find the person they want (I've no faith that they will pick the right person by the way) then it isn't a terrible idea.

None of that is to say that getting rid of Ole is not the right thing to do, it absolutely is. They should be getting rid of Solskjaer and putting an interim in charge across the next week or so then going for a new manager to come in after the City game which gives them a few days on the training pitch after that.


 

 

05 Oct 2021 15:25:15
Slight change of topic from the future of Ole (but I suppose this is somewhat linked as its relates to results) . Our next 10 games are about as tough as we can have at this stage of the season:
Leicester, Atalanta, Liverpool, Spurs, Atalanta, City, Watford, Villarreal, Chelsea and Arsenal.

Realistically, how many wins would you expect from this run of games? What is par for the course here? Maybe something like 5 wins, 2 draws and 3 defeats.

Rjmanutd

1.) 05 Oct 2021 15:57:49
We win them all. May be a draw against Atalanta.


2.) 05 Oct 2021 16:25:18
Leicester - draw
Atalanta - win
Liverpool - lose
Spurs - draw
Atalanta - lose
City - lose
Watford - win
Villarreal - draw
Chelsea - lose
Arsenal - win.


3.) 05 Oct 2021 16:30:41
If we come out of that run of games 3-5 points off the top I think we will have done well. We haven't taken advantage of the fact the other sides up around the top have already taken points off each other whilst we played sided who were and will be further down the table.


4.) 05 Oct 2021 15:42:41
That’s the million dollar question with United you have no idea because it’s all about which players turns it on on the day.

Where as if it was Liverpool or City playing those fixtures it would be much easier to hazard a guess, ok you may get 1/ 2 wrong, but in general you know

With us that’s my main problem you could win all 10 or you could lose all 10 no one would be surprised by either…. Ok maybe winning all 10 is a stretch but you know what I mean.


5.) 05 Oct 2021 17:36:59
I think we will draw every single game.


6.) 05 Oct 2021 18:51:28
Manc man think we will beat Leicester but lose to arsenal.


7.) 05 Oct 2021 19:04:45
Grim ? made me laugh that.

I think if the fan pressure for him to play Ronaldo every game prevails we won’t beat Liverpool, their high tempo means we need all 11 working hard, I hope Ole makes strong calls as they are going to be needed.


8.) 05 Oct 2021 20:01:49
It's a grim set of fixtures. I would be very pleased with 4 wins from that lot but think even that is optimistic.


9.) 06 Oct 2021 01:06:05
Ken, maybe because Leicester are out of form but Arsenal are serial chokers and Utd are at home.


10.) 06 Oct 2021 06:19:18
Christmas is always round the corner with Ole at the wheel.

There is always a surprise waiting in the wings and I am very sure these fixtures are going to spring up a lot more.


11.) 06 Oct 2021 06:41:12
Last season when Arsenal couldn't buy a win we gifted them one at Old Trafford.


 

 

29 Aug 2021 19:32:02
Lucky to come away with any points today never mind the 3. I'm delighted we won but this performance and the one last week against Southampton are very worrying. We played like this too often last season and dropped stupid points, unless something changes it looks to be going the same way.

Varane was solid today, Sancho still finding his feet but is hampered by how slow much of our play is at times. Greenwood is a star.

Fred was his usual self and the less said about James the better. Cannot fathom how Donny has yet to see a minute on the pitch this season with Fred putting in performances like this.

Rjmanutd

1.) 29 Aug 2021 19:48:52
It was a rubbish performance and only positive was a good debut for Varane and De Gea's world class save.

Does anyone see any identity or pattern in our play? What do these coaches do on the training ground?


2.) 29 Aug 2021 20:38:09
Absolutely no idea what they do in training or what our game plan is 80% of the time.


3.) 29 Aug 2021 21:12:06
RJ let’s be fair and clear here, you can’t come on and criticise James and then say Sancho is hampered by our slow play . Be grown up and honest and say it how it is, James was poor, Sancho was dreadful, needs to pull his finger out and tune in quickly.


4.) 29 Aug 2021 21:45:02
Chris, for me the difference is Sancho has a track record of providing goals, assists and generally playing in an eye catching way at a high level. He's also starting his first game for us. He wasn't good today I'll admit. If he's still like that in 6-12 months then I'll change my tune and say he should be doing more and it's not just the tactics or settling in period.

James on the other hand, while hard working and diligent has simply never shown the same qualities that Sancho has.


5.) 29 Aug 2021 21:52:46
Spot on Chris.


 

 

 

Rjmanutd's rumour replies

 

Click To View This Thread

26 May 2022 09:46:24
Bailly, Lindelof and Maguire aren't good enough in my opinion but the best thing a player can be is available. Bailly simply never is, his injuries have been an issue since his first season and he should be first out of the door in my opinion.

On our CB's, I'm really wanting to see Mengi given a chance at some pointas he looks like he could be a good player. It's all well and good having these promising young players, however, if they never get the chance or we send them to a club that has been picked out of a hat on loan they will stall. We've seen it with plenty of players in the past few years, Fosu Mensah, Henderson, Gomes, Tuanzebe, Dalot etc. Not saying all or even any of them would have become world beaters but their treatment when they were clearly too good for u23's hasn't been great at United and we've seen too many not live up to what they possibly could have been due to it.

Rjmanutd

 

 

Click To View This Thread

04 May 2022 20:51:42
----------------Wrong page--------------------

Rjmanutd

 

 

Click To View This Thread

03 May 2022 09:50:15
PSG seems the most likely landing spot for him if he were to leave you'd imagine? Not many other top sides who could pay the wages or have the need for Ronaldo as it stands.

Personally, I hope he stays simply because we have enough problems to solve without also losing our top scorer.

Rjmanutd

{Ed002's Note - Possibly but there is certainly another option already of the table. We will see what happens.}


 

 

Click To View This Thread

14 Apr 2022 13:49:23
Thanks for the update Ed002, I'd certainly be disappointed to see Rashford leave, he looked like a player to build a squad around a couple of years ago. Have a good day.

Rjmanutd

 

 

Click To View This Thread

31 Mar 2022 18:26:23
Cheers Ed.

Rjmanutd

 

 

 

Rjmanutd's banter replies

 

Click To View This Thread

22 May 2022 11:09:15
He will have better options than United I'd guess, just whether those options would be willing to pay what both Barcelona and De Jong would want.

We will now doubt be in the mix to sign him if possible but I'd be surprised if we actually get him, even if he does leave.

Despite that, I think he'd be a very good signing and would give us a player in the middle of the park who is brilliant on the ball, can pass and who works within the system being implemented. We haven't had that since Carrick retired.

Rjmanutd

 

 

Click To View This Thread

18 May 2022 11:26:19
I'd be wary of him playing at centre back early on based on his size and potential to deal with the physicality and speed in the Premier League, however, he certainly looks to be an excellent prospect.

His ability to play a couple of position is also something our squad actually needs.

Rjmanutd

 

 

Click To View This Thread

09 May 2022 13:25:30
I really want to believe the club is changing for the better and letting Pogba go is part of that, as is seeing some of the people upstairs leaving and Ten Hag coming in.

However, I can't let go of the feeling that this summer we're going to end up with Pogba signing a new deal, Martial, Donny and Pereira coming back and the club line on them is that they are "like new signings" and our main big signing ends up being our 8th choice defensive midfielder.

Rjmanutd

 

 

Click To View This Thread

01 May 2022 14:20:20
Garner deserves a chance. He has stood out for Forest all season in a very difficult league and in cup games against PL opposition. He has composure on the ball which is something our midfield sorely lacks.

If we had given him the minutes of Matic, McTominay or Pogba this season we'd have been no worse. Same goes for Mengi in place of our CB's.

Rjmanutd

 

 

Click To View This Thread

27 Apr 2022 14:12:13
If it's only 3 we can pick I'll go CB, DM and RW.

I'd go for Timber or Kounde as the CB for the simple fact they are both potentially very good CB's but can also help us cover our right back issues when needed.

There are a lot of players we could sign for DM/ CM like Rice, Phillips, Ndidi, Palhinha etc. However, I'd go for Tchouameni ahead of everyone except for Frenkie De Jong but I think he's a pipe dream to be honest so Tchouameni it is.

Finally a right winger, someone like Raphinha or Antony would be good. Bring some pace and dribbling ability to that side of our attack.

Next summer you sign the striker to replace Ronaldo and a couple of others like a right back, left back and another midfielder.

Rjmanutd